Deductive Method in Economics
The deductive method is a systematic approach to studying an economic issue where the analysis moves from general to specific. In this method, we do have a general theory, idea, or concept, and we want to test such idea in a specific context; then the method we follow is deductive.
Since we do have a general theory or idea that specifies the relationship between the variables, this method is called “A Priori”.
This method was mostly used by the classical economists. For eg, Say’s “law of markets” states that supply creates its own demand, which means aggregate supply and aggregate demand are equal. This is a general theory, and if we want to test this theory in Nepal’s case, we follow the deductive method.
As a systematic approach, we follow the following steps under the deductive method. →
- Step 1: Problem identification
- Step 2: Assumption and hypothesis testing
- Step 3: Data collection
- Step 4: Data analysis, interpretation, and conclusion
Inductive Method in Economics
In this method, we move from specific to general: we collect information from a representative number of cases, draw conclusions, and generalize them. So, this method is used to develop new theory, idea, or concept. This method is known as the empirical method, which was introduced in economics by the historical school of economists.
Since it is a systematic method of studying an economic issue, it normally follows the following steps:
- Step 1: Problem identification
- Step 2: Data collection
- Step 3: Data analysis
- Step 4: Conclusion and generalization
Difference Between Deductive and Inductive Method
| Deductive Method | Inductive Method |
|---|---|
| General to specific approach | Specific to general approach |
| Known as Priori or abstract method | It is empirical method |
| Mostly used by classical economists | Mostly used by historical economists |
| Used for theory testing | Used for theory building |
| Follow top-down approach | Follows button-up approach |
| Theory → Hypothesis → Observation → Confirmation | Observation → Pattern → Hypothesis → Theory |
Deductive & Inductive Method – Which one is better? Why?
Both inductive and deductive method have their own relative merits and demerits, and so it is not possible to decide which one is absolutely better than the other. It depends on the objective and context to decide the relative superiority of one method over the other.
If our objective is to test the validity of any economic theory in a specific context, then we need to use the deductive method. Similarly, if the objective is to develop a new idea or theory, then we use the inductive method. This means the objective of the study makes one method better than others.
Similarly, there may be a situation in which either the deductive or inductive method can be used separately. For example, if we do not have the required information or it is not possible to collect such information due to economic or technical reasons, then we can not use the inductive method. So the only option is to use the deductive method.
There may be a situation in which no existing theories or ideas are available to explain the situation. In this case, only the inductive method can be used, which collects fresh information and develops the theory.
However, it is agreed that the inductive and deductive methods are not substitutes but complementary to each other. So, for a complete scientific study of the economy, both methods should be used as per the requirement.
Deductive methods provide logic and arguments, while inductive methods provide data and facts. Data without logic or arguments are simply numbers that do not explain anything. Similarly, logic without facts is simply arguments and is not acceptable. This means that inductive and deductive methods make a complete study.
In the words of Schomoller as “both feet are required for healthy walking. So, as the inductive and deductive method for a complete scientific study of the economics”.
